Why the Order of Investment Returns Matters During Withdrawals

A calculator, planning notebook and wooden symbol counters arranged on a desk.
AI-created conceptual illustration; not an account statement, book cover or market data.

A retirement projection can look reassuring when it shows one average annual return. The difficulty is that bills arrive in particular years, including years when investments fall. The order of returns therefore deserves its own place in the example.

Charles Schwab’s explanation of sequence-of-returns risk describes why poor returns early in a withdrawal period can have lasting consequences. The calculation below is our own simplified illustration. It is not a forecast, a recommended withdrawal rate or a model of any particular investment.

Same two returns, different order

Start with $100,000. Assume a $10,000 withdrawal at the end of each year, after that year’s investment return. Ignore fees, taxes, inflation and all other cash flows so that the ordering effect is visible.

  • Loss first: a 20% fall leaves $80,000. Withdraw $10,000, leaving $70,000. A 25% rise in year two brings this to $87,500; the second withdrawal leaves $77,500.
  • Gain first: a 25% rise produces $125,000. Withdraw $10,000, leaving $115,000. A 20% fall in year two brings this to $92,000; the second withdrawal leaves $82,000.

Both paths use a 20% loss and a 25% gain. Both withdraw $20,000 in total. Yet the ending balances differ by $4,500. Without withdrawals, either order would return this particular starting sum to $100,000, because 0.8 multiplied by 1.25 equals 1.

The withdrawal changes what can recover

After the early loss, the first portfolio has less money remaining when the positive return arrives. The later gain applies to $70,000, not to the original $100,000. An average alone hides that changing base.

The timing assumption also matters. Taking money at the start of each year would produce different results. So would varying the withdrawal amount, adding contributions or including investment costs. A careful explanation should state those choices beside the result.

Questions to keep beside a retirement book

Does its example use a constant return or an uneven sequence? Are withdrawals fixed in currency or recalculated as a percentage? When do they occur? What happens if the first few years are weaker than expected?

This two-year exercise cannot determine a sustainable personal spending plan. It shows why a plan needs to consider timing, spending needs and uncertainty together. For decisions about an actual portfolio, those details belong in an assessment of your circumstances rather than in a universal rule taken from one attractive average.